The Duchy of Cornwall’s decision to sell its 3,000-acre Bradninch estate in Devon, and with it the farms of nine tenant families, took less than a day to travel from a Sunday newspaper to The Farming Forum. The conversation that followed spent far less time on the Prince of Wales than on a harder trade question: what security a farm tenancy in England actually gives, and whether the Scottish answer, a tenant’s right to buy, would help or hurt.
By TFF News | 30 October 2026 | Land
The conversation drew 144 visible contributions between 26 and 29 October 2026, and had been viewed 5,803 times when counted on 30 October. Contributions attracted 288 reactions, an average of 2.0 per contribution. A forum conversation is not a representative survey of the sector; these figures describe this conversation only.
A March announcement that became an October row
The sale is not new. The Duchy told Bradninch tenants in March that the estate near Cullompton would be sold with sitting tenants offered first refusal, and The Herald reported chief executive Will Bax describing tough decisions taken for social and environmental impact across the portfolio. What reignited it was The Observer’s investigation of 25 October, under a headline quoting a tenant: Charles was fantastic, William can go to hell. FarmingUK’s report says nine farming tenants are affected, that The Observer saw notices described as possession orders, some with a six-month deadline to buy or leave, and that the sale sits within a strategy to sell roughly 20 per cent of the Duchy’s portfolio by value over a decade, proceeds going to housing, renewable energy, environmental improvements and farming resilience. Farmers Guardian reported the Duchy rejecting the idea of a programme of mass evictions.
Two early contributions set the poles. One caught the critics’ mood: “Rather ironic that tenants are being made homeless in order to help the homeless.” The most reacted-to contribution of all was the unsentimental reply: “Renting anything you always know one day you might be asked to leave, unfortunatly over time people convince themselves they never will.” Others set the sale’s stated purpose against the landlord’s own income: “William could use the 23milluon annual income to help the homeless”, one wrote, in line with the nearly £23m annual private income The Herald reports.
Buy now, or gamble on buying
FarmingUK reports that eight of the nine tenants are exploring buying some or all of their holdings, on discounted terms reflecting length of tenure and improvements, with the Duchy contributing to professional costs. Some saw the chance of a lifetime: “Buy the farm at a discount & then sell it at a premium & retire, you will never make easier money!” The reply came back that “Most tenants will have earned that and some.”
The sharpest pushback was about timing rather than principle: “Three farms locally been for sale for at least 6 months to a year, all good farms with decent buildings/ land etc, been owner occupied, all for sale for genuine reasons ( death/ divorce etc ) and they cant even get any bids on them, they are just not moving.” The same contributor asked what happens if “a duchy tenant takes out a bridging loan in a very tough trading time for the industry on the back of the SFI shambles/ two years of severe summer droughts etc then cant sell the farm, then what?” A secondhand account of Duchy asking prices running 25 to 35 per cent above independent valuations went untested in the conversation; FarmingUK reports the Duchy is taking specialist advice on how tenant-funded improvements should be reflected in the prices asked.
The Scottish comparison
The conversation was started by a Scottish tenant arguing it was “High time u southerners had a pre emptive right to buy as scotland has had for 25 yrs”. Under the Agricultural Holdings (Scotland) Act 2003, tenants with secure 1991 Act tenancies who register their interest with Registers of Scotland get first refusal if the landlord decides to sell. English contributors were not convinced the import would help: “It has helped existing tenants to buy perhaps, but it can’t be helping new entrants to rent anywhere to get their foot on the first rung.” The argument against is that every strengthening of the tenant’s hand shrinks what landlords will let at all.
What security does an FBT give?
Tenancy security was the largest theme, carrying 43 contributions. A contributor who sat on a young farmers committee when farm business tenancies were designed in the 1990s offered the long view: “FBTs made slightly more available, but they are too far in the landlord’s favour, as opposed to AHA being too far in the tenant’s favour.” For the critics, insecurity is the whole point. “Gone are the days when estates offered genuine opportunities. There haven’t been genuine opportunities with security of tenure since the early 80’s.”, one wrote, in a contribution arguing that short terms let landlords capture tenants’ improvements, an opinion no landlord was present to answer. The most vivid image came from the opener: “Building a busineess on an fbt is like building a house on a clifftop or a swamp.”
The defence was equally direct. “FBTs are only poverty traps for those who are too desperate to keep on the hamster wheel.”, wrote one tenant holding several because the rents run far below the cost of buying the same rough ground. Another put the entrepreneurial case: “There are plenty of farmers who started off on small units with FBTs and got bigger by being good at business.”, and answered the risk argument with “Take no risks, get no reward.” A contributor farming in Ireland described what no tenanted sector looks like: “Young people either pay a ransom for land from April to November, or they buy land and farm part-time with a job to pay for the land.”
The history argument
Under the whole conversation ran land reform history, a reminder that owner-occupation is itself the product of policy: “Over 90% were tenants before death duties came along. The break up of these estates was not some unforeseen consequence, it was one of the aims of the policy.” His challenge to today’s owner-occupiers drew agreement: “I suspect none would and if that’s the case they shouldn’t try to tell today’s tenants they are in the wrong for wanting the same thing their ancestors got.” The counterargument: “Where then is the liquidity in any future rental market, and where is the opportunity for new entrants?” Selling land to its tenants, as Ireland and Denmark once did, only works once.
The question the trade is left with
The Duchy is not leaving the landlord business. Three weeks before the Observer investigation, it let the 900-acre Monkhall Farm in Herefordshire to a 25-year-old on a 25-year regenerative farm business tenancy, the first of its kind on the estate, pointed to in the conversation as the other side of the ledger. Eight of the nine Bradninch tenants are weighing a purchase in a land market contributors describe as stagnant after two drought years. If the Duchy of Cornwall, the landlord whose tenancies were a byword for permanence, is rationalising its let estate, the question the conversation leaves for the trade is who will be offering the first rung of the farming ladder in ten years, and on what terms.
Read the source conversation and analysis
Read the full conversation on The Farming Forum here.
Agri Web Media’s nine-slide analysis of the conversation, with engagement, sentiment and theme charts, is available as a PDF: Download the conversation analysis deck.
This conversation had been viewed 5,933 times on The Farming Forum when counted on 1 November 2026. Want your brand in the room when farmers talk land? Book advertising with Agri Web Media.

