Red Tractor’s own survey puts retailers on top

Red Tractor asked its members what they honestly made of it, and farmers on The Farming Forum followed the exercise from January’s survey email to June’s published findings. The number the conversation settled on was 82: the share of surveyed farmers who believe retailers dominate supply chain decision-making. For the trade, it is a candid read on how assured producers now weigh the scheme that sits between them and their buyers.

By TFF News | 16 November 2026 | Assurance

The conversation ran from 16 January to 26 June 2026 and gathered 108 visible contributions, 3,696 views and 254 reactions, an average of 2.35 reactions per contribution. Not one contribution read as positive in tone: 84 were critical and 24 neutral. These figures describe one self-selected conversation among Red Tractor members and their critics; they are not a representative survey of the sector.

An honest fifteen minutes

In mid January, Red Tractor members received an email from Grounded Research, an independent agricultural research specialist, asking for fifteen minutes of honest views on assurance. Those who filled it in described much the same approach. “Sadly for them I had to be honest and quite negative.” wrote one. Another was blunter about where he thought the scheme’s attention should be: “Didn’t hold back. The general gist of my message to them was that I consider them to be fiddling while Rome burns – particularly for combinable crops competing with non assured imports.”

Doubts about the design surfaced early. One contributor, who still urged fellow members to take part, worried that “because it’s been commissioned by RT, the full results won’t be made public and there will always be some nuggets that can be mined and either spun as a win for RT, or used to beat us with”.

The number that came back

The survey, published by Red Tractor, ran for six weeks across January and February 2026 and drew responses from 1,916 members across the UK, followed by four online focus groups in March. The finding the conversation seized on sits under Red Tractor’s own heading: 82% of respondents said they believe retailers dominate supply chain decision-making. The scheme’s chair of board, Alistair Macintosh, responded in the published findings that the perception is disappointing “because it does not reflect the balanced representation on our boards and advisory committees”, and that decisions are reached through collaboration and consensus.

The same publication carries the scheme’s weakest scores on its own measures: net performance ratings of minus 37 on commitment to reducing the audit burden, minus 34 on understanding farming pressures and minus 34 on listening and acting on feedback, against a rating of plus 43 for food safety, traceability and animal welfare.

The framing had been predicted five months earlier. “Whatever the results of the survey, I’m sure it will be spun into a win for RT…” wrote one in January. When the findings were briefed in June, media coverage led on the companion Consumer Trust in Food Index, which reported 94% of consumers trusting UK food and 80% trusting British farmers. The farmer findings drew less attention. “They’re just refusing to read the room.” wrote one contributor. Another turned the survey question around: “A better question would be, who benefits the most from the supply chain decisions made?
Its not those at the beginning of the chain.”

Who sits at the table

The retailer-dominance finding fed the conversation’s longest argument, over who actually represents farmers inside the scheme. The independent UK Farm Assurance Review, published in January 2025 after being commissioned by the farming unions and AHDB, had already called for schemes to establish farmers as the driving voice in standards development and for Red Tractor to complete the governance changes recommended in the Campbell Tickell report. Contributors did not believe the balance had shifted.

One contributor who said he had been close to board roles at both Red Tractor and AHDB described why he walked away: “Every farmer (some good guys, in fact) I have ever spoken to who either sits or has sat on a red tractor board tells me they are completely outvoted and may as well not be in the room.”

Others directed the frustration at the farmer side of the table rather than the scheme itself. For one, “it feels like retailers reps are forceful and agile in arguing their side while NFU and AHDB are generally not great at pushing back on our behalf”. Another agreed: “It appears to me that the problem lies with our reps on the RT Board. They are failing to deliver our message clearly and are bulldosed into poor decisions by the overall Board.”

The reviews themselves drew limited faith: “red tractor don’t want to change, the reviews to them were just an inconvenience.”

The import comparison

Underneath the governance argument sits the commercial one, sharpest for combinable crops, because assured UK grain competes at home with imports carrying no equivalent scheme. “NFU just find themselves in a funny position. They complain about imports not meeting our standards, and then are happy to put EXTRA standards/costs onto our own producers.” wrote one contributor. Another put the question at its simplest: “The question they never answer is what advantage RT membership gives over imports.

Overseas producers have access to the UK market without it.”

A livestock producer reported the same gap at the other end of the chain: “I was at two of our local livestock markets,recently, and there was no indication which sheep were RT,VAN or non assured.I asked an auctioneer who replied that nobody cared.”

Red Tractor has acknowledged the pressure point: in the June coverage its deputy chief executive said the Farm Assurance Review had recommended more transparency around standards for imported grain, which the scheme fully supports.

Where assurance stops

The conversation’s most practical stretch tested what assurance actually certifies once grain leaves the farm. “What happens when a RT farmer fails his assessment and his grain is all mixed in a central storage set up ?” asked one contributor. Another, drawing on his own experience of assessments, answered: “No one fails. They just correct an error, email it across and all is well. Another part of the farce.” The room’s understanding was that certification lost after grain has entered a central store does not touch what is already in the heap. One contributor rejected that logic: “If someone has failed their assurance visit, then to my mind that grain isn’t assured. Doesn’t matter if it’s in the farmer’s own store, on a lorry, in a central store or at a mill.” The exchange closed on the blunt version of the argument: “Assurance on grain is worthless once it’s left the farm on a lorry anyway. But it’s a valid point.”

What the trade is left weighing

For all the heat, the conversation’s bottom line is commercial. “I don’t begrudge any assurance providing it returns a worthwhile/return on investment for my business, currently it does not and does not look like too.” wrote one contributor, who now looks for outlets where assurance is not required. Yet the scheme’s reach is not collapsing: “I have spoken to several young farmers in beef and sheep and even though they know they can sell without assurance, they seem sold on being RT assured.” noted another.

Red Tractor’s new chief executive has said rebuilding farmer trust is a key focus, and the scheme now holds its own evidence on where that trust is thinnest: audit burden, listening, and the question of who holds the pen. The unresolved question for the trade is whether members see those scores move before the next survey lands, and whether assurance can show the return on investment its paying members keep asking it to prove.


Read the source conversation and analysis

Read the full conversation on The Farming Forum here. A nine-slide analysis of the conversation, with engagement, sentiment and theme breakdowns, is available as a PDF: download the conversation analysis deck.


This conversation had been viewed 3,696 times on The Farming Forum when counted on
16 November 2026. Want your brand in the room when farmers talk assurance?

Book advertising with Agri Web Media
.